[過去ﾛｸﾞ] Inter-universal geometry と ABC予想 50 (1002ﾚｽ)
上下前次1-新

---

このｽﾚｯﾄﾞは過去ﾛｸﾞ倉庫に格納されています｡
次ｽﾚ検索 歴削→次ｽﾚ 栞削→次ｽﾚ 過去ﾛｸﾞﾒﾆｭｰ

---

744(3): 2020/04/20(月)00:59 ID:lnvD9PiA(1/6) AAS
なかなか痛烈な批判
これ擁護できないだろ

>W says:
>April 19, 2020 at 9:53 am
>…
>(1) The first couple hundred pages of the IUT papers introduce a lot of difficult new terminology.
>Scholze and Stix demonstrated that none of this new terminology is necessary
>to prove any of the formal statements in these pages.
>Moreover, when the new terminology is ignored, the proofs all become simpler and easier to understand.
>They all follow quickly from Mochizuki’s previous work on the p-adic Grothendieck conjecture.
>…
>As an editor or referee, this should be completely unacceptable.
>Even if the proof is technically correct in the sense that
>Mochizuki or someone else can give a clear and precise argument
>which the proof of Corollary 3.12 could be said to summarize,
>allowing the paper to continue in its present form would be a failure at their duty
>to ensure papers in their journal properly explain their arguments.
>A paper such that everyone who studies it seriously,
>except a small inner circle, gets stuck at the same point simply isn’t a proper explanation.
>…

外部ﾘﾝｸ:www.math.columbia.edu

---

上下前次1-新書関写板覧索設栞歴

---

あと 258 ﾚｽあります
ｽﾚ情報 赤ﾚｽ抽出 画像ﾚｽ抽出 歴の未読ｽﾚ AAｻﾑﾈｲﾙ

---

ぬこの手 ぬこTOP 0.011s