ChatGPTに質問してみた (742ﾚｽ)
上下前次1-新
抽出解除 必死ﾁｪｯｶｰ(本家) (べ) 自ID ﾚｽ栞 あぼーん
707: ブタ耳◆ItTVBiGIl2 (ﾜｯﾁｮｲ 11b5-VeWP) 03/06(木)01:21 ID:qxlxR/UB0(1/4) AAS
# text
Paradoxically enough, to understand how verbal messages do their sociocultural work in communication, we need to think about the nonverbal practice of pantomime. This silent performance art form consists entirely of movements of the body and its various parts in an otherwise seemingly empty space. From the flow or sequence of such movements, the mime’s spectators come to see that the sequence of body and facial movement is tracing some culturally coherent event or recognizable experience in a specific frame of objects, populated physical spaces, and social situations that are "virtually"present.
# prompt
Describe the meaning of the last phrase, "that are virtually present".
# question
Why is the word "virtually" enclosed in quotation marks?
続く
708: ブタ耳◆ItTVBiGIl2 (ﾜｯﾁｮｲ 11b5-VeWP) 03/06(木)01:21 ID:qxlxR/UB0(2/4) AAS
ChatGPT:
The phrase “that are ‘virtually’ present” refers to how the objects, spaces, and social situations in a mime performance are not physically there but are instead implied through the performer’s movements and expressions. The audience perceives them as if they were present, even though they do not actually exist in the physical space.
The word “virtually” is enclosed in quotation marks to indicate that the presence of these elements is not literal but rather perceived or imagined. The quotation marks suggest a special or nonstandard use of the term, emphasizing that these elements exist only in the minds of the audience as a result of the mime’s performance.
続く
709: ブタ耳◆ItTVBiGIl2 (ﾜｯﾁｮｲ 11b5-VeWP) 03/06(木)01:22 ID:qxlxR/UB0(3/4) AAS
Prompt:
A certain stubborn English learner in Japan insists that this "that are virtually present" means "that exist in reality. His argument is that pantomimes imitate "real" objects, not "imaginary" ones.
What are the flaws in this argument?
710: ブタ耳◆ItTVBiGIl2 (ﾜｯﾁｮｲ 11b5-VeWP) 03/06(木)01:23 ID:qxlxR/UB0(4/4) AAS
ChatGPT:
There are several flaws in this argument:
1. Misinterpretation of “virtually” – The learner assumes “virtually” means “actually” or “in reality,” but in this context, it means “almost” or “as if present.” The quotation marks around “virtually” highlight that these objects are not physically real but only perceived through performance.
2. Confusion Between Representation and Existence – While pantomime does imitate real-world objects, those objects themselves are not actually present on stage. A mime might act as if they are holding a rope, but there is no physical rope—only the illusion of one created through movement.
3. Ignoring the Role of Audience Perception – The meaning of the phrase relies on the audience’s ability to infer the presence of objects, spaces, and situations. The objects are “virtually present” because they exist in the perception of the spectators, not in physical reality.
4. Overlooking the Function of Quotation Marks – The quotation marks around “virtually” suggest a non-literal usage. This implies that the objects and spaces are present only in an abstract or perceived sense, not in an actual, physical way.
The learner’s argument confuses the fact that pantomime references real-world objects with the idea that those objects must be physically present in the performance. However, the essence of pantomime is that it creates the illusion of reality without the actual presence of real objects.
上下前次1-新書関写板覧索設栞歴
ｽﾚ情報 赤ﾚｽ抽出 画像ﾚｽ抽出 歴の未読ｽﾚ AAｻﾑﾈｲﾙ
ぬこの手 ぬこTOP 0.023s